Hoppa till innehållet
Radio Logo
PoddsändningarBöckerAscend - The Great Books Podcast

Ascend - The Great Books Podcast

Harrison Garlick and Adam Minihan
Senaste avsnittet

160 avsnitt

  • Ascend - The Great Books Podcast

    A Roundtable Discussion on Gyges’ Ring (357a-362c)

    2026-11-17 | 1 h 33 min.
    Would you still be just if no one was watching?
    What if you could do whatever you wanted and never suffer the consequences?
    And if justice is only useful for its effects, why not take the reputation and leave the reality?
    On Ascend, we already walked through the basic shape of Glaucon’s challenge with Dr. Jennifer Frey. This roundtable is different. It is a slower, richer conversation about what the passage is really doing and who is speaking it. Glaucon is introduced as “most courageous.” Does that single line change how you hear the rest of his speech? Is the extreme picture he paints—the just man who is whipped, racked, and crucified—also a test he is putting to himself? Could he endure that for justice?
    More Resources on Plato’s Republic:
    How to Read Plato
    Reading schedule, podcast calendar, and more!
    GUIDE: 12 Questions on Book One of Plato’s Republic
    Republic Bk 1: Intro, Prologue & Cephalus with Dr. Alex Priou (327a-331d)
    Republic Bk 1: Polemarchus with Dr. Grabowski & Lackey (331e-336a)
    Republic Bk 1: Thrasymachus with Dr. Gregory McBrayer (336a-354c)
    GUIDE: 24 Questions on Book Two of Plato’s Republic
    Republic Bk 2: Gyges’ Ring with Dr. Jennifer Frey (357a-362c)
    Republic Bk 2: Adeimantus’ Reaction with Dr. Papadopoulos (362d-369b)

    Dr. Grabowski asks whether the shepherd already reveals his nature before he ever puts the ring on. Thomas Lackey brings in a range of literary parallels, including St. Ambrose’s reading of the just man who suffers. Dr. Larson traces the social-compact argument forward to Hobbes and asks how close Glaucon’s anthropology really is to the modern version. Dr. Diduch presses on whether Glaucon is fully coherent or already divided against himself, and he names the three questions the rest of the Republic will still have to answer: the origin of the city, the hope for inner harmony, and the superlative hope that justice can answer even death.
    If you have already heard the first episode on this section, this one is still worth your time. It stays closer to the text, presses harder on the man who is speaking, and leaves you with clearer questions for the books that follow. The passage continues to set the terms for everything else in the Republic.
    Come listen and wrestle with it again.
    Be sure to check out our entire reading schedule (it is revised at times if we have to reschedule a recording).
    God bless.
    Chapters
    00:00 Why the opening of Book II matters
    04:02 Paul Deduc on principled leadership and Plato
    08:34 Glaucon renews Thrasymachus’s challenge
    11:36 Socrates’ strategy and Glaucon’s good faith
    18:06 Glaucon’s courage and the just man’s suffering
    21:06 Can justice be good despite extreme hardship?
    26:20 Glaucon’s anthropology: what would people do?
    32:31 The Ring of Gyges as a test of human nature
    38:12 Does the shepherd’s behavior prove Glaucon’s case?
    44:13 Why Glaucon is drawn to power and injustice
    49:23 The ring’s cost: isolation and moral corruption
    53:50 Tyranny, Tolkien, and false freedom
    58:21 Why Plato links Gyges to Herodotus
    01:05:08 Two Gyges stories, two kinds of agency
    01:08:20 Invisibility and the divided self
    01:13:09 Justice, the gods, and the stories cities teach
    01:15:05 Glaucon’s social compact and Hobbes
    01:18:37 Is human nature self-seeking or social?
    01:21:14 Why the argument turns toward theology
    01:24:14 Naturalism was already shaping the city
    01:27:08 What kind of person do you want to become?
    01:30:06 Three questions for close readers of the Republic
    01:32:54 What comes next in the Book II reading
  • Ascend - The Great Books Podcast

    Republic Book Two: Adeimantus & Socrates’ Reaction with Dr. Pavlos Papadopoulos (362d-369b)

    2026-11-10 | 1 h 28 min.
    Today on Ascend: The Great Books Podcast, Dr. Pavlos Papadopoulos join us to discuss our second episode on Book Two of the Republic: Adeimantus & Socrates’ Reaction to Glaucon’s Proposal (362d-369b).
    After Glaucon rebuilds Thrasymachus’ case and presses it harder, Adeimantus steps forward and makes the challenge still more serious. He does not simply add another clever argument. He shows how thoroughly the ordinary teaching of the city has already shaped him and his brother. The poets, the fathers, and the common opinion of Athens have all said, in one way or another, that the best life is to appear just while being unjust, so that a man receives the rewards of both. Adeimantus wants Socrates to answer not only the case for injustice, but the formation that has made that case seem reasonable.
    Dr. Pavlos Papadopoulos helps us see why this moment matters. Adeimantus is not a sophist. He is a young man who has absorbed what the culture has been teaching him, and that teaching already treats justice as useful mainly for its consequences. The conversation opens onto larger questions about how a city actually educates its citizens, about the decay of traditional religion, and about what happens when justice is no longer defended for its own sake. Socrates is struck by the force of the request. He says something divine must have happened, because the two brothers are pressing him to defend justice itself. The task is heavier than the one Glaucon alone had set, and Socrates accepts it.
    More Resources on Plato’s Republic:
    How to Read Plato
    Reading schedule, podcast calendar, and more!
    GUIDE: 12 Questions on Book One of Plato’s Republic
    Republic Bk 1: Intro, Prologue & Cephalus with Dr. Alex Priou (327a-331d)
    Republic Bk 1: Polemarchus with Dr. Grabowski & Thomas Lackey (331e-336a)
    Republic Bk 1: Thrasymachus with Dr. Gregory McBrayer (336a-354c)
    GUIDE: 24 Questions on Book Two of Plato’s Republic
    Republic Bk 2: Gyges’ Ring with Dr. Jennifer Frey (357a-362c)

    Rather than offering a direct definition, Socrates proposes that they look for justice first in a city and then look for the same thing in the soul. This is the famous turn to the city in speech, the move that gives the Republic its name. Dr. Papadopoulos walks carefully through what this decision does and does not mean, and why some readers have taken the city as a practical proposal while others have taken it as an enlarged picture of the soul. Either way, the turn is already a claim about the nature of justice and about what can be said in the present company.
    This is one of the decisive turns in the dialogue.
    The brothers have forced the question of whether justice is good for the soul even when it brings no rewards, and Socrates has taken up the challenge. The written guide for this section tracks the argument closely and will help you keep the structure clear as you listen. If you are reading the *Republic* with us, the episode is both a companion to the text and a reminder of why this book continues to press on the question of how a person ought to live.
    Be sure to check out our entire reading schedule, so you can be sure to read alongside us (it is revised at times if we have to reschedule a recording).
    I am humbled to read the Republic alongside you all.
    God bless.
    Chapters
    00:00 Why Adamantus deserves a closer reading
    03:22 Papadopoulos’ long return to the Republic
    08:00 How justice leads to metaphysics and theology
    11:47 Adamantus’ role beside Glaucon
    15:05 Why fathers and poets cannot answer Glaucon
    20:01 A younger generation shaped by moral crisis
    25:11 Thucydides, Athens, and the logic of might
    32:03 Can sacrifices make the unjust man dear to the gods?
    38:14 Theology and the limits of poetic authority
    44:19 Why justice must be good in itself
    57:08 Socratic philosophy as a form of piety
    01:03:05 Civic religion, philosophy, and the opening scene
    01:09:00 Piety toward family, city, and God
    01:11:16 Why begin the city-soul analogy?
    01:19:43 Is the Republic a political blueprint or an ethical inquiry?
    01:24:24 Reading Glaucon and Adamantus as distinct characters
  • Ascend - The Great Books Podcast

    Republic Book Two: Gyges’ Ring with Dr. Jennifer Frey (357a-362c)

    2026-11-03 | 1 h 35 min.
    Today on Ascend, we open Book Two of Plato’s Republic with one of the most striking passages in the whole work: the myth of the Ring of Gyges. Glaucon does not simply disagree with Socrates. He says he has been talked to death by Thrasymachus and countless others, and he wants to know whether Socrates is trying to persuade him or only to seem to persuade him. He then restores the argument for injustice in its strongest form.
    Justice, he says, is a compact struck by the weak. Those who practice it do so unwillingly. And the life of the unjust man is, after all, far better than that of the just. To make the claim vivid he tells the story of Gyges, who finds a ring that makes him invisible, seduces the queen, kills the king, and takes the throne.
    Dr. Jennifer Frey joins me to walk through the argument, and she is clear that this is no mere academic exercise. Plato is mapping the options that are still with us. The seeds of Machiavelli and Hobbes are already here.
    What makes the section so powerful is the way Glaucon strips justice of every external reward. He imagines a man of perfect injustice who has a reputation for justice, and then a man of perfect justice who has a reputation for injustice. The just man, they will say, will be whipped, racked, bound, have both his eyes burned out, and at the end, when he has undergone every sort of evil, he will be crucified. Dr. Frey notes that he will be treated like Christ. Plato is writing about his master, Socrates, but the parallel is unavoidable. The question the passage forces on the reader is simple and severe: is justice good in itself, or only for its effects? Glaucon wants the second kind of good. He wants to be shown that justice is desirable for its own sake and for what comes from it. Everything that follows in the Republic is an attempt to answer him.
    More Resources on Plato’s Republic:
    How to Read Plato
    Reading schedule, podcast calendar, and more!
    GUIDE: 12 Questions on Book One of Plato’s Republic
    Republic Bk 1: Intro, Prologue & Cephalus with Dr. Alex Priou (327a-331d)
    Republic Bk 1: Polemarchus with Dr. Grabowski & Thomas Lackey (331e-336a)
    Republic Bk 1: Thrasymachus with Dr. Gregory McBrayer (336a-354c)
    GUIDE: 24 Questions on Book Two of Plato’s Republic

    If you are reading the Republic with us, this is the section that sets the stakes. The drama is part of the pedagogy. You cannot extract the argument and leave the myth behind. The question is first (i) what is justice and second (ii) is justice more profitable for the soul than injustice. That is the problem Book Two places before us, and it is the problem the rest of the dialogue will try to solve—at least on its face.
    Chapters
    00:00 Book II reading guide and the central question of justice
    04:29 Dr. Jennifer Frey on why The Republic remains a masterwork
    07:14 How Plato anticipates modern political philosophy
    10:14 Why Plato’s literary form is part of the argument
    14:05 Glaucon challenges Socrates to defend justice
    17:08 Three kinds of goods and where justice belongs
    22:19 Glaucon’s three-part case for injustice
    24:45 Glaucon seeks reasons, not just persuasion
    29:38 Justice as a compromise against mutual harm
    34:49 Socrates’ maxim: better to suffer than commit injustice
    37:53 The Ring of Gyges and the test of justice
    42:13 Invisibility, power, and the gap between appearance and reality
    45:35 Can an unjust person truly flourish?
    47:23 Gyges, Superman, and what power reveals
    49:45 Plato’s magical ring and Herodotus’s political coup
    52:04 Does power immediately cast moral norms aside?
    53:33 Virtue as the long cultivation of appetite
    55:02 Thrasymachus, legal positivism, and power
    57:17 Justice as a compact or a reality beyond rulers
    59:43 Universals, nominalism, and where meaning comes from
    01:01:20 Why Glaucon thinks injustice can benefit the individual
    01:04:35 Justice as a virtue of the soul, not just a social system
    01:08:18 Religion, sacrifice, and whether the gods see the soul
    01:10:16 Doing a just act versus becoming a just person
    01:13:11 The soul, cosmic justice, and the afterlife
    01:16:40 The perfectly just person with an unjust reputation
    01:18:39 Why Plato’s just sufferer recalls Christ and Socrates
    01:21:27 Why Glaucon’s challenge remains a serious argument
    01:23:41 How Plato and pagan philosophy shaped Christian thought
    01:27:34 Glaucon’s case: the tyrant’s apparent happiness
    01:31:39 What counts as the highest good and a happy life
    01:34:25 Closing reflections and where to find Jen Frey
    Be sure to check out our entire reading schedule, so you can be sure to read alongside us.
  • Ascend - The Great Books Podcast

    How Plato Shaped Christianity with Dr. Louis Markos

    2026-10-27 | 1 h 48 min.
    Today on Ascend: The Great Books Podcast, Deacon Harrison Garlick and Mr. Thomas Lackey sit down with Dr. Louis Markos—author of From Plato to Christ—for a lively, wide-ranging conversation on how Platonic thought prepared the world for the Gospel.
    From the fullness of time and the meeting of Athens and Jerusalem to C.S. Lewis, classical education, the myths of the Republic, and why even modern Christians still need Plato, this is a rich exploration of the intellectual roots of the faith and the enduring power of the Great Books.
    Dr. Markos is a whirlwind on a mission.
    Join us.
    And THANK YOU again to the Classic Learning Test for sponsoring this episode.
    Dr. Markos opened by framing his lifelong project of uniting Athens and Jerusalem—the Greco-Roman and Judeo-Christian inheritances that together shaped the West. He argued that the “fullness of time” was not only political and linguistic but intellectual: Greek philosophy, especially Plato, prepared the human heart for the Gospel through general revelation. God did not ignore the nations; He used reason, conscience, and imagination to plant redemptive analogies that pointed toward Christ.
    Dr. Markos noted that this recovery is now happening among evangelicals, who are reclaiming the classical tradition just as many secular universities abandon it, and that classical Christian education is quietly reintroducing Plato, the Church Fathers, and a hierarchical view of reality to a generation once wary of anything outside the Bible alone.
    The conversation then turned to Plato’s specific role as a kind of pre-evangelism. Dr. Markos distinguished Socrates’ negative work of clearing false definitions from Plato’s positive construction of the Good, the True, and the Beautiful. He highlighted how the Republic uses the just and unjust man, the city-soul analogy, and the Myth of Er to show that injustice disorders the soul itself—an insight modern students often encounter first in Plato rather than in Scripture. Myths, he explained, are not mere stories for those who cannot grasp philosophy; they incarnate truths that pure dialectic cannot fully express, especially the reality of final judgment and the damage sin does to the soul.
    Deacon Garlick and Thomas Lackey pressed further on St. Augustine’s decisive Christianization of the Forms: relocating them in the divine Logos and affirming that God knows both universals and particulars, so that Platonic metaphysics is not an alien overlay but something already latent in the New Testament’s language of participation, shadows, and heavenly patterns.
    The episode closed with C.S. Lewis as the modern bridge who makes Plato accessible to Protestants. Dr. Markos pointed to the heavenly Narnia that is “more real” than the earthly one, the Silver Chair’s psychological undoing of the children’s knowledge of Aslan and the sun, and Lewis’s consistent realism against nominalism.
    Throughout, the guests returned to the practical stakes of the Republic for first-time readers: follow the through-line that justice is better than injustice even when it costs everything, let the allegory of the cave reorient what counts as real, and treat Plato not as an opponent to be purged but as a candle whose light is completed, not extinguished, by the greater light of Christ.
    If you’re interested in reading more on how Plato and the broader Hellenized culture impact the Gospel, check out “Do Christians Owe a Debt to Homer” and “How Plato Helped St. Augustine Convert to Christianity.”
    Good work!
    Next week we start Book Two of the Republic. Check out our reading schedule for more information.
    Chapters
    00:00 Why discuss Plato’s impact on Christianity
    00:28 Myth, sin, and what our actions do to the soul
    03:06 Meet Lou Markos and the Athens-Jerusalem connection
    04:00 Why poetry’s ambiguity can deepen meaning
    07:06 Greek thought and general revelation
    09:03 Plato’s influence on Scripture and Christian thought
    11:05 Classical education’s return among evangelicals
    13:58 Augustine, Aristotle, and the nature of universals
    18:20 How Markos came to Plato
    18:47 How C.S. Lewis brings Plato to life
    22:03 Plato’s ideas, Christian language, and pre-evangelism
    25:06 The Silver Chair and the reality behind appearances
    29:00 Recovering metaphysics and the unseen world
    30:55 Why Christians need the classics and Church Fathers
    32:16 Augustine, the candle, and the greater light of Christ
    34:51 Advice for reading Plato’s Republic
    35:19 The Magi, natural reason, and the journey to faith
    41:08 Why the Republic still speaks to modern readers
    45:16 Justice, the soul, and the tyrant’s inner slavery
    50:10 What Plato’s myths reveal about cosmic justice
    Keywords
    Plato and Christianity, Louis Markos, From Plato to Christ, classical education, general revelation, Plato's Republic, Augustine, Christian philosophy, Socrates, metaphysics Lou Markos, Plato, Christianity, Platonic thought, Augustine, Aristotle, C.S. Lewis, The Republic, Chronicles of Narnia, Christian philosophy
  • Ascend - The Great Books Podcast

    Republic Book One: Thrasymachus with Dr. Gregory McBrayer (336a-354c)

    2026-10-20 | 2 h 4 min.
    Today on Ascend: The Great Books Podcast, Deacon Harrison Garlick and guest Dr. Gregory McBrayer dive into the fiery third part of Book One of Plato’s Republic: the showdown between Socrates and the sophist Thrasymachus.
    Thrasymachus bursts onto the scene “hunched up like a wild beast,” roaring that justice is nothing more than “the advantage of the stronger.” What follows is a masterclass in Platonic drama and pedagogy—complete with forced feedings, blushing, and precision battles over definitions—as Socrates methodically unravels the sophist’s position.
    And THANK YOU again to the Classic Learning Test for sponsoring this episode.
    Dr. McBrayer and Dcn. Garlick explore why this confrontation matters so much. They compare Thrasymachus to the even more ferocious Callicles of the Gorgias (which Dr. McBrayer also discussed with Dcn. Garlick on Ascend) and discuss whether Socrates truly refutes him or merely “out-sophists the sophist.” They also go back and forth on the famous shepherd-and-sheep analogy, the arts-versus-money-making distinction, and the early hints of the philosopher-king and city-soul analogy.
    Along the way they surface deeper questions that haunt the rest of the dialogue: Is justice a real thing or merely a name the powerful give to their own advantage? Why does Plato bookend the Republic with religious myths? And how much of Book One is a deliberate deconstruction meant to clear the ground for Glaucon’s more serious challenge in Book Two?
    More Resources on Plato’s Republic:
    How to Read Plato
    Reading schedule, podcast calendar, and more!
    GUIDE: 12 Questions on Book One of Plato’s Republic
    Republic Bk 1: Intro, Prologue & Cephalus with Dr. Alex Priou (327a-331d)
    Republic Bk 1: Polemarchus with Dr. Grabowski & Thomas Lackey (331e-336a)

    Whether you’re a first-time reader still finding your footing or a returning student who wants to wrestle with one of the most famous attacks on justice in the Western tradition, this conversation models how to read Plato slowly, dramatically, and in good company. Tune in for sharp analysis, unexpected humor, and a clear sense of why Thrasymachus still feels so familiar—and so dangerous—today.
    Be sure to check out our entire reading schedule, so you can be sure to read alongside us.
    A good path is before us.
    Let’s take it and ascend.
    Chapters
    00:00 — Introducing Thrasymachus and the end of Book One
    13:00 — Thrasymachus and Callicles: comparing the “nasty” challengers
    21:00 — Thrasymachus’s dramatic entrance—and why to take him seriously
    31:00 — “Justice is the advantage of the stronger”
    40:00 — Ruling as an art, and Socrates’ argument
    52:00 — The shepherd, the sheep, and Thrasymachus’s shifting claims
    66:00 — The soul, leadership, and the reluctant ruler
    81:00 — The penalty of being ruled by someone worse
    93:00 — Justice, injustice, and Thrasymachus’s defeat
    106:00 — What Book One establishes—and what it leaves unresolved
Fler podcasts i Böcker
Om Ascend - The Great Books Podcast
Welcome to Ascend! We are a weekly Great Books podcast hosted by Deacon Harrison Garlick and Adam Minihan. What are the Great Books? The Great Books are the most impactful texts that have shaped Western civilization. They include ancients like Homer, Plato, St. Augustine, Dante, and St. Thomas Aquinas, and also moderns like Machiavelli, Locke, and Nietzsche. We will explore the Great Books with the light of the Catholic intellectual tradition. Why should we read the Great Books? Everyone is a disciple of someone. A person may have never read Locke or Nietzsche, but he or she thinks like them. Reading the Great Books allows us to reclaim our intellect and understand the origin of the ideas that shape our world. We enter a "great conversation" amongst the most learned, intelligent humans in history and benefit from their insights. Is this for first-time readers? YES. Our goal is to host meaningful conversations on the Great Books by working through the texts in chronological order in a slow, attentive manner. Our host Adam Minihan is a first-time reader of Homer. We will start shallow and go deep. All are invited to join. Will any resources be available? YES. We are providing a free 115 Question & Answer Guide to the Iliad written by Deacon Harrison Garlick in addition to our weekly conversations. It will be available on the website (launching next week). Go pick up a copy of the Iliad! We look forward to reading Homer with you in 2024.
Podcast-webbplats

Lyssna på Ascend - The Great Books Podcast, Förlagspodden och många andra poddar från världens alla hörn med radio.se-appen

Hämta den kostnadsfria radio.se-appen

  • Bokmärk stationer och podcasts
  • Strömma via Wi-Fi eller Bluetooth
  • Stödjer Carplay & Android Auto
  • Många andra appfunktioner
Sociala nätverk
v8.27.0 | © 2007-2026 radio.de GmbH
Built: 11/16/2026 - 1:18:40 PM